Best Whodunit Books December 2024

Now You See Them

In “Now You See Them,” Elly Griffiths weaves a captivating tale of mystery and intrigue set against the backdrop of 1960s Brighton. Detective Inspector Edgar Stephens and his wife, former magician Emma, find themselves entangled in a perplexing case of missing schoolgirls. As the investigation unfolds, old friends and new faces collide, unearthing long-buried secrets. Griffiths’ keen eye for period detail and her knack for crafting complex characters shine through, making this a page-turner I couldn’t put down. A must-read for fans of atmospheric crime fiction.

The Postscript Murders

I found myself utterly captivated by Elly Griffiths’ “The Postscript Murders.” It’s a delightfully clever mystery that had me guessing until the very end. The characters are so vivid, I felt like I was solving the case alongside them. Griffiths’ witty prose and intricate plot weave together beautifully, creating a cozy yet thrilling read. I couldn’t put it down, staying up way too late just to finish one more chapter. A perfect blend of humor and suspense for any mystery lover.

The Stranger Diaries

Clare Cassidy’s life takes a chilling turn when her colleague is found dead, a line from a Gothic story by R.M. Holland beside her body. As a literature teacher specializing in Holland’s work, Clare is drawn into a sinister mystery that blurs fiction and reality. With her own diary entries appearing altered and a menacing presence lurking, Clare must unravel the truth before she becomes the next victim. Griffiths weaves a spine-tingling tale that kept me up late, jumping at every creak in my old house.

Buried in Secret

In this gripping new installment, Detective Inspector Vera Stanhope faces her most perplexing case yet. When a body is unearthed during a routine archaeological dig, Vera’s instincts tell her this is no ancient burial. As she delves deeper, she uncovers a web of long-buried secrets in the close-knit coastal community. With her trademark wit and tenacity, Vera must navigate treacherous waters to solve the mystery before another life is lost. Cleeves’ masterful storytelling kept me guessing until the very end.

The Sleeping and the Dead

Detective Peter Porteous is called to a remote Scottish island when a body is discovered in a peat bog. As he delves into the case, he uncovers long-buried secrets and a web of lies that have haunted the tight-knit community for decades. With each revelation, Peter finds himself drawn deeper into the island’s dark history, risking everything to unravel the truth. Cleeves masterfully weaves a tale of suspense and human nature, keeping readers guessing until the very end.

The Moth Catcher

In “The Moth Catcher,” Ann Cleeves weaves a haunting tale of secrets and suspense in the Northumberland countryside. When a body is discovered in a remote valley, Detective Vera Stanhope is drawn into a complex web of lies and hidden motives. As she unravels the mystery, Vera confronts her own demons, grappling with the isolation of rural life and the weight of unsolved cases. Cleeves’ masterful prose brings the rugged landscape to life, making it as much a character as the enigmatic locals. A gripping read that will keep you guessing until the very end.

The Crow Trap

In “The Crow Trap,” Ann Cleeves weaves a gripping tale of murder and secrets in the rugged Northumberland countryside. Three women, each harboring their own hidden truths, find themselves drawn into a web of deceit when a body is discovered near their remote field center. As the investigation unfolds, long-buried tensions surface, and loyalties are tested. Cleeves’ masterful storytelling keeps readers guessing until the very end, blending atmospheric descriptions with complex characters in this haunting mystery that lingers long after the final page.

Telling Tales

In “Telling Tales,” Ann Cleeves weaves a gripping mystery that haunts a small village for a decade. When a young girl’s murder case is reopened, Detective Inspector Vera Stanhope arrives to unravel the truth. As she digs deeper, long-buried secrets surface, threatening to shatter the community’s fragile peace. Cleeves’ masterful storytelling and complex characters kept me guessing until the very end. A perfect read for those chilly nights when you crave a good, old-fashioned whodunit.

Silent Voices

Detective Vera Stanhope’s latest case plunges her into the murky world of secrets at a local health club. When a body is discovered in the sauna, Vera’s instincts kick in. As she peels back layers of lies, she uncovers a web of jealousy and betrayal. The victim’s past holds the key, but getting people to talk proves challenging. Vera’s unorthodox methods ruffle feathers, but her keen insight might just crack the case. A gripping mystery that kept me guessing until the very end.

Dead Water

Ann Cleeves delivers another gripping Shetland mystery in “Dead Water.” When a journalist is found dead in a traditional Shetland boat, Detective Jimmy Perez is drawn back from grief to investigate. As he unravels the victim’s past, he discovers a web of secrets and lies that reaches far beyond the isolated islands. Cleeves’ vivid prose brings the windswept landscape to life, while her nuanced characters and intricate plot keep readers guessing until the very end. A masterful addition to the series that’ll have you longing for a cozy sweater and a dram of whisky.