Best Supernatural Books May 2025

The Water Dancer

Hiram Walker’s life as a slave on a Virginia plantation is shattered when he discovers an extraordinary power: the ability to transport himself across vast distances through water. This gift, passed down from his mother, becomes both a blessing and a curse as Hiram navigates the treacherous world of the Underground Railroad. Coates weaves a spellbinding tale of love, loss, and the unbreakable bonds of family, painting a vivid portrait of antebellum America that will haunt you long after the last page. A stunning debut novel that blends historical fiction with magical realism, leaving readers breathless and yearning for more.

The Immortalists

Imagine knowing the exact date of your death. Four siblings, curious and daring, seek out a mysterious fortune teller who claims to predict just that. As they grow up, each grapples with this knowledge differently, shaping their lives in unexpected ways. From the vibrant streets of 1960s New York to the glittering stages of Las Vegas, their paths diverge and intertwine, haunted by the question: Is our destiny predetermined, or do we shape it ourselves? A poignant exploration of family, fate, and the choices that define us.

The Outsider

In a small town, a beloved Little League coach is arrested for a horrific crime. Eyewitnesses and DNA evidence point to his guilt, but he has an ironclad alibi. Detective Ralph Anderson, grappling with personal demons, is drawn into a perplexing case that defies logic. As the investigation deepens, unsettling questions arise, blurring the line between reality and the supernatural. King masterfully weaves a chilling tale that will keep you guessing until the very end.

Wuthering Heights

Emily Brontë’s “Wuthering Heights” is a haunting tale of passion and revenge set on the windswept moors of Yorkshire. The story follows the tumultuous relationship between the enigmatic Heathcliff and his childhood love, Catherine Earnshaw. Their intense bond, thwarted by societal expectations, spirals into a destructive force that engulfs two generations. Brontë’s vivid prose and complex characters create a Gothic masterpiece that explores the depths of human emotion and the consequences of unchecked desire. A timeless classic that still captivates readers with its raw intensity and atmospheric brilliance.

The Sea of Monsters

Percy Jackson’s summer at Camp Half-Blood is anything but peaceful. When Thalia’s tree, which protects the camp, is poisoned, Percy and his friends embark on a perilous quest to find the Golden Fleece. Battling mythical creatures and facing treacherous waters, they navigate the Sea of Monsters. With humor and heart, Riordan weaves Greek mythology into a modern adventure, keeping readers on the edge of their seats. I couldn’t put it down, rooting for Percy every step of the way.

The Shack

Nestled in the Oregon wilderness, “The Shack” tells a heart-wrenching tale of loss and redemption. Mack, still reeling from his daughter’s tragic disappearance, receives a mysterious invitation to revisit the scene of his deepest pain. What unfolds is a soul-stirring journey that challenges everything he thought he knew about faith, forgiveness, and the nature of God. Young’s prose is raw and honest, weaving a story that tugged at my heartstrings and left me pondering long after the final page.

Dreamcatcher

In this chilling tale, four childhood friends share a telepathic bond and a dark secret from their past. When a blizzard traps them in the Maine woods, they encounter a mysterious stranger and a terrifying alien force. As they fight for survival, long-buried memories resurface, testing their friendship and sanity. King masterfully weaves horror and nostalgia, creating a gripping story that will haunt readers long after the final page. A thrilling ride through the human psyche and the unknown.

Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children

Discover a world of mystery and wonder in Ransom Riggs’ “Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children.” As I turned each page, I was drawn deeper into Jacob’s journey, uncovering family secrets and a hidden realm of extraordinary individuals. Riggs’ masterful blend of eerie vintage photographs and captivating prose creates a hauntingly beautiful atmosphere that lingered in my mind long after I finished reading. This isn’t just a book; it’s an experience that will leave you questioning the boundaries between reality and the impossible.

Inkspell

Dive back into the enchanting world of Inkheart with Cornelia Funke’s spellbinding sequel, Inkspell. Meggie and her father Mo find themselves drawn into the magical realm they once read about, where fantasy and reality blur. As they navigate this perilous landscape, filled with familiar characters and new dangers, Meggie discovers her own hidden powers. Funke’s vivid prose brings the story to life, making you feel as if you’ve stepped into the pages yourself. A thrilling adventure that will captivate readers of all ages.

Inkheart

Twelve-year-old Meggie’s world turns upside down when she discovers her father’s secret ability to bring characters from books to life. As dark forces from a mysterious novel threaten their family, Meggie must confront her own fears and uncover hidden strengths. Funke’s enchanting tale weaves magic, danger, and the power of storytelling into a spellbinding adventure that will leave readers breathless. I couldn’t put it down, staying up late to finish just one more chapter. A must-read for book lovers of all ages.