Best Supernatural Books May 2025

Before the Devil Breaks You

Dive into the thrilling world of 1920s New York in this gripping tale of supernatural intrigue. As the Diviners grapple with their newfound powers, a sinister force lurks in the shadows, threatening to unravel everything they hold dear. Bray’s masterful storytelling weaves together history and fantasy, creating a rich tapestry of characters you can’t help but root for. With each page, I found myself more entangled in their lives, feeling the weight of their choices and the pulse of a city on the brink of change. A haunting, atmospheric read that’ll keep you up well past midnight.

Lair of Dreams

Dive into the glittering, dangerous world of 1920s New York in this spellbinding sequel. As a mysterious sleeping sickness grips the city, Evie and her supernatural friends must navigate a realm where dreams and reality blur. Bray’s lush prose brings the Jazz Age to life, weaving together romance, mystery, and the occult. With richly drawn characters and heart-pounding suspense, this book kept me up way past my bedtime, totally engrossed in its dreamlike atmosphere. A thrilling adventure you won’t want to wake up from.

The Diviners

Evie O’Neill’s sharp tongue lands her in hot water in Ohio, forcing her parents to ship her off to Manhattan. But 1920s New York City holds more than speakeasies and jazz for Evie. Her uncanny ability to “read” objects reveals a sinister connection to a serial killer terrorizing the city. Teaming up with her uncle and a ragtag group of misfits, each with their own supernatural gifts, Evie races to stop the murderer before it’s too late. Bray’s vivid prose brings the Roaring Twenties to life in this thrilling paranormal mystery that will keep you up all night.

The Mask Falling

Paige Mahoney, the dreamwalker, finds herself in a precarious position as she navigates the treacherous waters of Scion Paris. Torn between her loyalty to the rebellion and her growing feelings for Warden, she must make impossible choices that could alter the fate of both humans and voyants. Shannon’s vivid prose brings this dystopian world to life, weaving intricate politics with heart-pounding action. I found myself holding my breath during the tense undercover missions, feeling Paige’s internal struggle as if it were my own. A thrilling continuation of the series that left me eagerly anticipating the next installment.

The Song Rising

Paige Mahoney’s world is crumbling. As Underqueen of the Mime Order, she faces mounting threats from all sides. The Scion regime tightens its grip on London, while a dangerous new technology threatens to expose clairvoyants everywhere. Torn between loyalty and survival, Paige must navigate treacherous alliances and confront her own demons. As she uncovers shocking secrets about her past, she realizes the fate of her people rests on her shoulders. Shannon’s vivid prose brings this dystopian world to life, keeping readers on the edge of their seats until the very last page.

The Mime Order

Paige Mahoney’s world is shattered when she’s thrust into the criminal underworld of Scion London. Forced to navigate a treacherous landscape of rival gangs and shadowy figures, she must use her rare clairvoyant abilities to survive. As she uncovers a sinister plot that threatens everything she holds dear, Paige finds herself torn between loyalty and love. Shannon’s gripping prose and intricate world-building had me on the edge of my seat, desperately turning pages late into the night. A thrilling blend of dystopian fantasy and urban grit that left me craving more.

The Bone Season

In a dystopian London, Paige Mahoney navigates a dangerous underworld as a dreamwalker, a rare clairvoyant hunted by the government. When she’s captured and thrust into a hidden city ruled by powerful beings, she discovers her own untapped abilities. As she unravels the city’s secrets, Paige forms unlikely alliances and faces heart-wrenching choices. I couldn’t put it down, staying up late to devour just one more chapter. Shannon’s vivid world-building and complex characters left me craving the next installment in this thrilling series.

The Clockmaker’s Daughter

In a forgotten corner of London, an old house whispers secrets from the past. Birdie Bell, a skilled clockmaker’s apprentice, vanished without a trace in 1862. Over a century later, archivist Elodie stumbles upon a mysterious satchel containing a photograph of a hauntingly beautiful woman. As she unravels the threads connecting Birdie’s story to her own, Elodie discovers a tale of love, loss, and the enduring power of art. Morton’s evocative prose weaves a spellbinding mystery that spans generations, leaving readers captivated until the final page.

The Silent Corner

In “The Silent Corner,” Dean Koontz weaves a chilling tale of a woman’s quest for answers in a world gone mad. FBI agent Jane Hawk’s perfect life shatters when her husband inexplicably commits suicide. Driven by grief and suspicion, she uncovers a sinister conspiracy that threatens humanity’s free will. As Jane delves deeper, she becomes a fugitive, hunted by powerful forces. Koontz’s masterful prose keeps readers on edge, blending heart-pounding suspense with thought-provoking themes. A gripping thriller that’ll leave you questioning the world around you.

A Discovery of Witches

Diving into “A Discovery of Witches,” I was instantly captivated by Deborah Harkness’s rich tapestry of history, magic, and romance. The story follows Diana Bishop, a reluctant witch who stumbles upon an ancient manuscript that unleashes a world of supernatural intrigue. As I turned each page, I found myself lost in the atmospheric Oxford setting and drawn to the enigmatic vampire Matthew Clairmont. Harkness’s blend of scholarly detail and spellbinding fantasy left me eagerly anticipating the next installment in this bewitching trilogy.