Best Supernatural Books May 2025

Her Fearful Symmetry

Twins Julia and Valentina inherit their aunt’s London flat, a mirror image of their own. As they settle in, they’re drawn into the building’s mysterious past and the lives of its eccentric residents. Niffenegger weaves a haunting tale of love, loss, and the blurred lines between life and death. With each page, I found myself more entangled in the sisters’ eerie world, unable to shake the feeling that something wasn’t quite right. A beautifully crafted ghost story that lingers long after the final page.

Time’s Convert

Deborah Harkness’s “Time’s Convert” weaves a spellbinding tale of love, history, and vampiric transformation. As Marcus MacNeil grapples with his past and future, readers are transported between revolutionary America and modern-day Paris. Harkness’s rich prose brings to life the complexities of immortality, family bonds, and the weight of centuries-old secrets. I found myself completely immersed in this world, unable to put the book down as I followed Marcus’s journey of self-discovery and redemption. A must-read for fans of paranormal romance and historical fiction alike.

The Book of Life

Deborah Harkness’s “The Book of Life” weaves a spellbinding tale of love, magic, and ancient secrets. As Diana and Matthew return from their time-traveling adventure, they face new challenges that threaten their future. With richly drawn characters and a world steeped in history and lore, Harkness captivates readers, drawing them into a mesmerizing blend of romance, suspense, and supernatural intrigue. I found myself completely lost in the pages, savoring every twist and turn of this beautifully crafted conclusion to the All Souls trilogy.

Shadow of Night

Deborah Harkness’s “Shadow of Night” plunges readers into a captivating world of time travel and supernatural intrigue. As historian Diana Bishop and vampire Matthew Clairmont journey to Elizabethan London, they’re thrust into a dangerous web of politics, magic, and secrets. Harkness’s meticulous research brings the past to life, while her deft storytelling keeps you on the edge of your seat. I found myself completely lost in this rich, atmospheric tale, unable to put it down until the very last page.

The Virgin Blue

Ella Turner’s move to rural France stirs up unexpected emotions and vivid dreams about her enigmatic ancestor, Isabelle du Moulin. As Ella delves into her family’s past, she uncovers a haunting legacy of religious persecution and forbidden love. Chevalier weaves a mesmerizing tale that spans centuries, blending historical intrigue with contemporary self-discovery. Through vivid prose and rich detail, she explores the enduring power of family secrets and the quest for identity. A captivating read that will linger in your thoughts long after the final page.

The Binding

In a world where memories can be bound into books, young Emmett Farmer is apprenticed to a mysterious bookbinder. As he uncovers the secrets of his craft, he stumbles upon a forbidden volume—his own. Torn between curiosity and fear, Emmett delves into a past he can’t remember, uncovering a love story that challenges everything he thought he knew. Collins weaves a spellbinding tale of magic, romance, and the power of the written word, leaving readers breathless until the very last page.

The Essex Serpent

Sarah Perry’s “The Essex Serpent” is a mesmerizing tale of Victorian-era intrigue and romance. Set against the backdrop of a small English village, the story follows Cora Seaborne, a recently widowed amateur naturalist, as she investigates rumors of a mythical sea creature. Perry’s lush prose brings the marshy landscape to life, while her complex characters grapple with faith, science, and desire. I found myself completely absorbed in this atmospheric novel, feeling the damp chill of the Essex coast and the palpable tension between the main characters. A truly captivating read that lingers long after the final page.

The Ten Thousand Doors of January

In a sprawling mansion filled with peculiar treasures, January Scaller finds a strange book. As she reads, she’s swept into a story of love and longing, of adventure and sacrifice. The book speaks of Doors—portals to other worlds—and January discovers she possesses the power to open them. But her guardian, the wealthy Mr. Locke, will stop at nothing to keep her gift hidden. As January uncovers family secrets and her own identity, she must choose between safety and the wild freedom of endless possibilities.

The Once and Future Witches

In a world where witchcraft is whispered about but never openly practiced, three sisters discover their own magical heritage. Set against the backdrop of the suffragette movement, this enchanting tale weaves together history and fantasy, exploring the power of sisterhood and the magic of words. As the sisters uncover long-lost spells and confront societal expectations, they must decide how far they’re willing to go to reclaim their birthright. Harrow’s lyrical prose and richly drawn characters bring this alternate America to vivid life, making for a spellbinding read that lingers long after the final page.

Magic Lessons

Delving into the rich tapestry of the Owens family history, “Magic Lessons” weaves a spellbinding tale of love, loss, and the enduring power of magic. Set in 17th-century Salem, Hoffman’s lyrical prose brings to life the story of Maria Owens, the matriarch who started it all. As Maria navigates a world of prejudice and danger, her journey becomes a testament to the strength of the human spirit and the transformative nature of love. This enchanting prequel will captivate both longtime fans and newcomers alike.