Best Psychological Fiction Books April 2025

Z: A Novel of Zelda Fitzgerald

Zelda Sayre Fitzgerald, the wild and talented wife of F. Scott Fitzgerald, comes alive in this captivating novel. Fowler paints a vivid portrait of the Roaring Twenties, whisking readers through Jazz Age parties and expatriate life in Paris. As Zelda struggles to find her own identity beyond Scott’s shadow, we witness her passionate spirit and artistic ambitions. The author’s meticulous research shines through, offering a fresh perspective on one of literature’s most fascinating couples. I found myself completely absorbed in Zelda’s world, cheering for her triumphs and aching for her struggles.

The Betrayals

In “The Betrayals,” Bridget Collins weaves a mesmerizing tale of ambition, secrets, and forbidden love. Set in an elite academy where students compete in the mysterious grand jeu, the story follows Leo Martin as he returns to his alma mater, haunted by memories of a passionate affair. As he uncovers long-buried truths, Leo finds himself drawn into a dangerous game of power and deception. Collins’ lyrical prose and intricate world-building captivate, leaving readers questioning the nature of art, loyalty, and the price of greatness.

The Binding

In a world where memories can be bound into books, young Emmett Farmer is apprenticed to a mysterious bookbinder. As he uncovers the secrets of his craft, he stumbles upon a forbidden volume—his own. Torn between curiosity and fear, Emmett delves into a past he can’t remember, uncovering a love story that challenges everything he thought he knew. Collins weaves a spellbinding tale of magic, romance, and the power of the written word, leaving readers breathless until the very last page.

The Essex Serpent

Sarah Perry’s “The Essex Serpent” is a mesmerizing tale of Victorian-era intrigue and romance. Set against the backdrop of a small English village, the story follows Cora Seaborne, a recently widowed amateur naturalist, as she investigates rumors of a mythical sea creature. Perry’s lush prose brings the marshy landscape to life, while her complex characters grapple with faith, science, and desire. I found myself completely absorbed in this atmospheric novel, feeling the damp chill of the Essex coast and the palpable tension between the main characters. A truly captivating read that lingers long after the final page.

The Poppy War

Rin, a war orphan from a backwater province, defies expectations by acing the Empire’s brutal military exam. Thrust into an elite academy, she discovers a gift for shamanism��a power that could change the course of history. As war looms and dark forces awaken, Rin must confront her own demons and make impossible choices. Kuang’s debut is a gripping tale of magic, warfare, and the cost of power, leaving readers breathless and haunted long after the final page.

Everything I Never Told You

Lydia Lee is dead, but her family doesn’t know it yet. As the Lees grapple with their loss, long-buried secrets surface, revealing the complexities of love, identity, and belonging. Set in 1970s Ohio, this poignant tale explores the weight of expectations and the struggle to fit in. Ng’s masterful prose delves into the intricate dynamics of a mixed-race family, unraveling the threads that bind them together and the silences that tear them apart. A haunting, intimate portrait of family life that will linger in your thoughts long after the final page.

The Mothers

In a tight-knit Black community in Southern California, three young lives intertwine in unexpected ways. Nadia, reeling from her mother’s suicide, finds solace in the arms of Luke, the pastor’s son. Their secret romance leads to consequences that echo through the years, touching the lives of Aubrey, Nadia’s best friend, and the church mothers who watch over them all. Bennett’s poignant debut explores the weight of secrets, the power of friendship, and the complexities of motherhood in a tale that’s both heartbreaking and hopeful.

What Alice Forgot

Alice wakes up on the gym floor, thinking she’s 29 and madly in love. In reality, she’s 39, with three kids and a crumbling marriage. As she pieces together the lost decade, Alice grapples with how she became this stranger to herself. Funny and poignant, this novel explores identity, relationships, and second chances. It’s a thought-provoking journey that’ll make you ponder your own life choices and the power of perspective.

Truly Madly Guilty

Liane Moriarty’s “Truly Madly Guilty” is a gripping exploration of friendship, marriage, and the ripple effects of one fateful day. Set in suburban Sydney, the story revolves around three couples whose lives are forever changed by a seemingly ordinary barbecue. Moriarty’s keen insight into human nature shines as she unravels the complex web of secrets and regrets that bind these characters together. I found myself completely absorbed, turning pages late into the night, desperate to uncover the truth behind the mysterious incident. With her trademark wit and compassion, Moriarty delivers a thought-provoking tale that will linger long after the final page.

The Husband’s Secret

Cecilia Fitzpatrick’s life is picture-perfect: successful businesswoman, devoted wife, and loving mother. But when she stumbles upon a letter from her husband meant to be opened only after his death, her world shatters. As she grapples with the shocking contents, Cecilia finds herself entangled in a web of secrets that connects her to two other women in unexpected ways. Moriarty’s gripping tale explores the ripple effects of our choices and the power of truth to upend even the most carefully constructed lives.