Best Psychological Fiction Books April 2025

Every Last Lie

Clara’s world shatters when her husband Nick dies in a car crash, leaving her alone with their newborn son and four-year-old daughter. As she grapples with grief, Clara becomes obsessed with uncovering the truth behind Nick’s death. Haunted by her daughter’s cryptic comments and her own nagging suspicions, Clara delves into Nick’s past, unearthing secrets that threaten everything she thought she knew. A gripping tale of love, loss, and the lies we tell ourselves, “Every Last Lie” will keep you guessing until the very end.

The Other Mrs.

Sadie and Will Foust thought moving to a small Maine island would be the fresh start they needed. But when their neighbor is found dead, Sadie becomes entangled in the investigation, uncovering dark secrets that threaten her family’s safety. As she delves deeper, she questions everything she thought she knew about her husband and their new home. With twists that’ll keep you guessing, this psychological thriller explores the haunting power of lies and the lengths we’ll go to protect those we love.

The Paris Wife

Hadley Richardson never expected to fall for Ernest Hemingway, let alone become his wife. But their whirlwind romance sweeps her into the intoxicating world of 1920s Paris. Surrounded by artistic luminaries, Hadley struggles to find her place amidst the revelry and creative fervor. As Ernest’s star rises, their marriage faces challenges that test their love. McLain’s vivid prose brings Jazz Age Paris to life, capturing the passion and heartbreak of a woman caught in the shadow of a literary giant.

The Silver Star

Jeannette Walls’ “The Silver Star” is a poignant coming-of-age tale that tugged at my heartstrings. Set in 1970s Virginia, it follows two resilient sisters navigating abandonment and small-town life. Walls’ vivid prose transported me to a bygone era, evoking nostalgia and unease in equal measure. I found myself rooting for the plucky protagonists, their bond a beacon of hope amidst adversity. It’s a story that lingers, reminding us of the strength found in family ties and the power of perseverance.

On Mystic Lake

Annie Colwater’s world shatters when her husband confesses he’s in love with a younger woman. Fleeing to her hometown, she finds solace in the arms of an old friend, Nick Delacroix. As they rekindle their connection, Annie discovers a strength she never knew she had. Through the misty shores of Mystic Lake, Hannah weaves a tale of heartbreak, healing, and second chances. With lyrical prose and raw emotion, this novel explores the depths of human resilience and the power of love to mend even the most broken spirits.

Night Road

In “Night Road,” Kristin Hannah weaves a poignant tale of love, loss, and redemption. I was captivated by the way she explores the complexities of family bonds and teenage friendships. The story’s twists left me breathless, and I found myself staying up late, unable to put it down. Hannah’s vivid prose brings the Pacific Northwest setting to life, making you feel the mist on your skin. It’s a heart-wrenching journey that will resonate with anyone who’s ever loved deeply or faced impossible choices.

It Ends with Us

Lily’s life seems perfect on the surface—a successful business, a charming neurosurgeon boyfriend, and a fresh start in Boston. But her past haunts her, memories of her first love, Atlas, and an abusive father she left behind. When Atlas unexpectedly reappears, Lily’s carefully constructed world begins to crumble. As she grapples with conflicting emotions and painful truths, she must confront the cycle of abuse and make heart-wrenching choices. Hoover’s raw, honest portrayal of love, trauma, and resilience will leave you breathless and forever changed.

Verity

Lowen Ashleigh, a struggling writer, accepts a lucrative offer to complete the remaining books in a successful series for the injured author, Verity Crawford. As she delves into Verity’s notes, Lowen uncovers a chilling manuscript that reveals dark secrets about the Crawford family. Torn between her growing attraction to Verity’s husband and the disturbing truths she’s uncovering, Lowen grapples with ethical dilemmas and her own safety. This gripping psychological thriller kept me up all night, questioning reality and morality at every turn.

You Are Not Alone

Shay Miller’s life is unraveling. Jobless and alone, she witnesses a shocking incident that leaves her reeling. Desperate for connection, she’s drawn to the Moore sisters, who seem to have it all. As Shay becomes entangled in their glamorous world, she can’t shake the feeling that something’s off. Are these women really her saviors, or is there a darker motive behind their friendship? With each twist, Shay realizes she’s in deeper than she ever imagined. A gripping psychological thriller that will keep you guessing until the very end.

An Anonymous Girl

Jessica Farris stumbles into a psychology study for easy money, but finds herself caught in a web of deceit and manipulation. As the mysterious Dr. Shields pushes her boundaries, Jess begins to question reality and her own morality. With each twisted turn, she’s drawn deeper into a dangerous game where trust is a luxury she can’t afford. This gripping psychological thriller will leave you breathless, questioning who’s really pulling the strings in this masterful dance of deception.