Best Psychological Fiction Books April 2025

The Perfect Couple

Nantucket’s idyllic charm sets the stage for a wedding that promises perfection, but beneath the surface, secrets simmer. As the Otis family prepares for their daughter’s big day, unexpected twists unravel their carefully woven plans. With each turn of the page, I found myself drawn deeper into a web of lies, love, and loyalty. Hilderbrand’s vivid prose transported me to the island’s sandy shores, where the salty air carries whispers of scandal. A gripping tale that kept me guessing until the very end.

A Nearly Normal Family

Stella Sandell, a seemingly ordinary teenager, stands accused of murder. Her parents, a pastor and a defense attorney, grapple with the unthinkable as their perfect family unravels. As the trial unfolds, long-buried secrets emerge, challenging everything they thought they knew about each other. This gripping psychological thriller explores the lengths parents will go to protect their child, and the devastating consequences of lies and betrayal. With each twist, Edvardsson masterfully blurs the lines between right and wrong, leaving readers questioning their own moral compass.

The Good Samaritan

Sarah can’t bear the thought of another person taking their own life. As a volunteer for a suicide prevention helpline, she’s dedicated her nights to talking people back from the brink. But when she receives a call from a man determined to end it all, Sarah’s world is turned upside down. She becomes obsessed with saving him, crossing ethical lines and risking everything she holds dear. As their connection deepens, Sarah realizes she may have stumbled into a dangerous game where nothing is as it seems. A gripping psychological thriller that will keep you guessing until the very end.

The Last Anniversary

Sophie Honeywell inherits a house on Scribbly Gum Island, home of the famous Munro Baby mystery. Intrigued by the island’s quirky inhabitants and their secrets, she leaves her city life behind. As she unravels the truth about the decades-old disappearance, Sophie discovers unexpected connections to her own life. With Moriarty’s signature wit and insight, this captivating tale explores family, love, and the power of long-held secrets to shape our destinies.

Florida

Lauren Groff’s “Florida” is a mesmerizing collection of stories that delves deep into the heart of the Sunshine State. With her lyrical prose and keen eye for detail, Groff paints a vivid portrait of a place both beautiful and treacherous. From swampy wilderness to suburban sprawl, she explores the complexities of human nature against a backdrop of oppressive heat and lurking danger. Each tale is a haunting glimpse into lives shaped by this enigmatic landscape, leaving readers spellbound and slightly unsettled.

Fates and Furies

Lotto and Mathilde’s marriage seems perfect from the outside, a union of two beautiful, talented individuals destined for greatness. But beneath the surface lies a complex web of secrets, ambitions, and hidden truths. Groff’s masterful prose weaves through their entwined lives, revealing the stark differences in their perspectives. As the years unfold, we witness the power of perception and the lengths we go to protect those we love. A haunting exploration of marriage, identity, and the stories we tell ourselves to survive.

I Found You

In a sleepy seaside town, Alice finds a man on the beach with no memory of who he is or how he got there. Intrigued and compassionate, she takes him in, nicknaming him ‘Frank’. Meanwhile, in London, Lily’s new husband fails to come home from work. As Alice digs into Frank’s past and Lily searches for her missing spouse, their stories intertwine in unexpected ways. Jewell masterfully weaves a tale of mystery, love, and redemption that kept me guessing until the very end.

The House We Grew Up In

Nestled in the Cotswolds, the Picture-Perfect House holds secrets that span generations. As the Bird family gathers for Easter, long-buried tensions resurface, threatening to shatter their idyllic facade. Through laughter and tears, we witness the unraveling of carefully constructed lies and the strength of familial bonds. Jewell’s masterful storytelling weaves a tapestry of love, loss, and redemption, leaving readers questioning the true meaning of home and the power of forgiveness. A poignant exploration of family dynamics that will linger in your thoughts long after the final page.

Watching You

Melville Heights is a picturesque Victorian suburb, the kind of place where neighbors know each other and children play in the streets. But beneath this idyllic facade, dark secrets lurk. As newcomer Joey Mullen struggles to fit in, she becomes infatuated with her neighbor, Tom Fitzwilliam. Little does she know, she’s not the only one watching him. With each passing day, the lines between obsession and reality blur, leading to a shocking revelation that will shatter the community’s peaceful veneer. Jewell masterfully weaves a tale of suspense that’ll keep you guessing until the very end.

The Family Upstairs

Secrets lurk behind the polished facade of a London mansion, where three bodies lay rotting for years. As Libby Jones inherits the house on her 25th birthday, she uncovers a chilling past of cult-like manipulation and family betrayal. Jewell masterfully weaves together multiple timelines, revealing the dark truth piece by tantalizing piece. I couldn’t put it down, staying up way too late, completely engrossed in the twisted tale. A haunting exploration of family bonds and the lengths people will go to protect their own.