Best Mystery Books April 2025

The Things We Cherished

In “The Things We Cherished,” Pam Jenoff weaves a poignant tale of love, loss, and redemption across generations. As I turned each page, I found myself transported between present-day Philadelphia and war-torn Europe, following Charlotte Gold’s quest to uncover a family’s long-buried secrets. Jenoff’s vivid prose brings history to life, making you feel the weight of wartime choices and the enduring power of cherished memories. A haunting, beautifully crafted story that lingered in my mind long after I closed the book.

The Lost Girls of Paris

Grace Healey stumbles upon an abandoned suitcase in Grand Central Terminal, uncovering a trove of photographs that ignite her curiosity. As she delves deeper, she unravels the story of Eleanor Trigg and her team of female secret agents during World War II. Grace becomes obsessed with discovering the fates of these brave women, whose dangerous missions in Nazi-occupied Europe have been all but forgotten. Through her journey, she not only honors their memory but also finds her own path to healing and purpose.

Waiting for the Moon

In “Waiting for the Moon,” Kristin Hannah weaves a haunting tale of love and redemption. Set against the backdrop of a remote asylum in 1890s Washington, the story follows Selena, a mysterious woman with no memory, and Dr. Jed Harmon, the man determined to unlock her past. As they navigate the complexities of their growing attraction, dark secrets threaten to unravel everything they hold dear. Hannah’s lyrical prose and richly drawn characters make this a mesmerizing read that will stay with you long after the final page.

Magic Hour

As twilight descends on the rugged Olympic Peninsula, a wild child emerges from the forest, captivating a small town. Dr. Julia Cates, a child psychiatrist haunted by her past, sees a chance for redemption in this mysterious girl. With her sister’s help, Julia unravels the child’s secrets, confronting her own demons along the way. Hannah’s poignant tale explores the resilience of the human spirit and the healing power of love, leaving readers spellbound until the last page.

Verity

Lowen Ashleigh, a struggling writer, accepts a lucrative offer to complete the remaining books in a successful series for the injured author, Verity Crawford. As she delves into Verity’s notes, Lowen uncovers a chilling manuscript that reveals dark secrets about the Crawford family. Torn between her growing attraction to Verity’s husband and the disturbing truths she’s uncovering, Lowen grapples with ethical dilemmas and her own safety. This gripping psychological thriller kept me up all night, questioning reality and morality at every turn.

You Are Not Alone

Shay Miller’s life is unraveling. Jobless and alone, she witnesses a shocking incident that leaves her reeling. Desperate for connection, she’s drawn to the Moore sisters, who seem to have it all. As Shay becomes entangled in their glamorous world, she can’t shake the feeling that something’s off. Are these women really her saviors, or is there a darker motive behind their friendship? With each twist, Shay realizes she’s in deeper than she ever imagined. A gripping psychological thriller that will keep you guessing until the very end.

An Anonymous Girl

Jessica Farris stumbles into a psychology study for easy money, but finds herself caught in a web of deceit and manipulation. As the mysterious Dr. Shields pushes her boundaries, Jess begins to question reality and her own morality. With each twisted turn, she’s drawn deeper into a dangerous game where trust is a luxury she can’t afford. This gripping psychological thriller will leave you breathless, questioning who’s really pulling the strings in this masterful dance of deception.

The Wife Between Us

Vanessa thought she had it all—a perfect marriage, a luxurious lifestyle, and a doting husband. But when Richard leaves her for a younger woman, her world shatters. Obsessed with her replacement, Vanessa spirals into a web of jealousy and deceit. As she unravels the truth about her past and Richard’s new fiancée, nothing is as it seems. With each twist, readers will question their assumptions, caught in a psychological thriller that blurs the lines between victim and villain. Trust no one, not even yourself, in this heart-pounding tale of love, betrayal, and revenge.

Believe Me

Claire Wright, a struggling British actress in New York, takes on a new role: entrapping married men for suspicious wives. It’s just acting, until she’s hired to seduce Patrick Fogler, a charming psychologist suspected of murdering his wife. As Claire delves deeper into Patrick’s world, the line between reality and performance blurs. With each twist, she questions who’s manipulating whom. A gripping psychological thriller that keeps you guessing until the final curtain call.

The Girl Before

Haunting and seductive, “The Girl Before” weaves a tale of obsession and control. Emma and Jane, separated by time, both find themselves living in a minimalist architectural marvel with strict rules. As they uncover the house’s dark secrets and the enigmatic architect’s twisted games, their lives intertwine in unexpected ways. Delaney masterfully builds tension, leaving you questioning reality and relationships. I couldn’t put it down, my heart racing with each revelation. A psychological thriller that will linger in your mind long after the final page.